Benny Jr. is seen to like playing football with his dad, and also likes hunting in the neverside forest. He also seems to have a close friendship with Varg's neverside form as a Satyr. A creature of the Neverside, he vanished when he was rescued by Ursula Crowe and Benny Sherwood, never having existed in the real world. He was soon forgotten by both Tom and Lexi.
Tom and Lexi continue to dream about Benny Jr and their time in the Neverside. With help from the Burnt Hill Stone Circle, the pair are able to remember what happened in the Neverside.
When Lexi begins to die of Zanti Scale Contamination, Tom drinks raw magic from the Extractor. He becomes very powerful and changes Lexi into a human. He then brings Benny Jr back into reality to begin a new life with Lexi's human form, Lucy.